Review and Pilot Status

Curriculum readiness answers whether a teaching path is usable. Quality review records what independent evidence supports a stronger claim. The canonical quality data is content/portal/quality-matrix.json.

Dimension	Reviewed	Battle-tested	Evidence examples
Editorial	Required	Required	clarity, terminology, and link audit
Technical	Required	Required	reproduced code, commands, diagrams, and standards claims
Assessment	Required	Required	outcome mapping, calibration, transfer, and remediation review
Accessibility	Required	Required	document and required-artifact accessibility audit
Security	Required	Required	safe labs, secret handling, threat and disclosure review
External review	Not required	Required	named academic or practitioner review record
Learner pilot	Not required	Required	completion evidence, observed friction, and remediation

Build success and page count are necessary operational signals, but neither is review evidence.